The removable Storm Liner is the detail I didn't know I needed — I can pull it out to text without freezing my fingers, then pop it back in. Wore them skiing all weekend and my hands stayed dry the whole time.
Mia★★★★☆
Wore these shoveling for two hours in wet snow and my hands stayed dry the whole time. The removable liner is a nice touch for warmer days, though getting it back in takes some fiddling.
Lucy L.★★★☆☆
The touchscreen liner is handy for answering texts without pulling the mitt off, but it fits a little loose around the fingertips. Warm enough for a cold morning walk, though I wouldn't trust it below freezing.