These handled a muddy trail and then looked totally fine walking into a coffee shop afterward. The GTX waterproofing actually held up in wet grass, which I wasn't expecting from something this light.
Carter★★★★★
Wore these straight from the car into a muddy trail and they handled both without feeling clunky. The GTX lining kept my feet dry through wet grass, and they still look decent enough for grabbing coffee after.
Edward Z.★★★★☆
Wore these straight from the car into town and then onto a rocky path, and the GTX lining kept my feet dry through a damp morning. The chukka cut looks tidy enough for errands, though the ankle collar rubbed a little the first day before breaking in.